We declare that a huge Fuck universe cannot succeed particularly your state is maintained Author's reaction: Big-bang activities is actually obtained from GR by presupposing the modeled universe stays homogeneously filled up with a fluid regarding matter and you will radiation. The fresh refuted paradox is missing once the from inside the Big-bang models this new almost everywhere is limited to a finite volume. Reviewer's comment: The author is wrong in writing: “The homogeneity assumption is drastically incompatible with a Big Bang in flat space, in which radiation from past events, such as from last scattering, cannot fail to separate ever more from the material content of the universe.” The author assumes that the material content of the universe is of limited extent, but the “Big Bang” model does not assume such a thing. Figure 1 shows a possible “Big Bang” model but not the only possible “Big Bang” model. However, from inside the mainstream traditions, brand new homogeneity of the CMB is actually handled maybe not because of the Author's response: My statement holds for what I (and most others) mean with the “Big Bang”, in which everything can be traced back to a compact primeval fireball. [...]